As with David Yates’ previous entry, times are getting darker for Harry Potter, along with the tone, music, lights, colors, expressions, events and dialogue. Mortality is more startlingly realized and bloodletting isn’t as shied away from. This chapter also seems to strive for horror movie gimmicks, including screeching noises, high-pitched screams, sudden attacks, frightening dream sequences and plenty of dark environments. Even more disturbing than the scarier elements that represent the evil forces at work are the frequent unexplained scenes that introduce new characters, locations and powers. Many of these moments are set up for fans who clearly know what is transpiring – for anyone unfamiliar with the novels, these constant introductions of new ideas might be overwhelming, disjointed and obscure.
The familiar character of Dobby makes a brief reappearance and sums up the general note of dissatisfaction with Part I, when he’s asked if he’s capable of performing a teleportation task: “Of course, sir – I’m an elf.” The fact that every predicament can be solved by randomly executing a contrived bit of magic or casting a previously undefined enchantment gives the plot the feeling of making everything up as it progresses. Rather than having a clear path ahead, various subplots with their own pitfalls and fixes seem thrown in for the sake of padding the already expectedly lengthy running time. With no rules and no definitive boundaries for magic, anything can happen, and making sense within the realm of Harry Potter land and England/Scotland becomes less and less important. There’s still a smidgen of humor to top off the proceedings, but battles, spells, Mission: Impossible styled impersonations, the abundance of clues, riddles and secrets, silly names, a stylized animation segment, and weird, hallucinogenic horcrux spirits only adds up to an overflowing chain of believability hurdles in an epic, seemingly endless quest that borrows generously from George Orwell (chiefly 1984 and Animal Farm), Star Wars/Akira Kurosawa, The Lord of the Rings and well known ancient mythology.
- Mike Massie
Harry
Potter Franchise Home
Read
the Review of Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
Read
the Review of Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets
Read
the Review of Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban
Read
the Review of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
Read
the Review of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix
Read
the Review of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince
Read the Review of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
Part I
Read the Review of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
Part II
Yeah, htis wasn't much of a complete movie. It kind of left off on a cliffhanger too, so it really feels like part 1.