It’s an invasion of the inhuman, a revolution of doppelgangers,
an army of body snatchers. It’s like playing inside of a
video game, or plugging into “The Matrix,” where all
of the senses can be used to their fullest extent, all while the
“operator” is in the safety of a cushy bed. But it’s
like “The Island,” “I, Robot,” “The
Stepford Wives,” “Minority Report,” “Terminator”
(and even “Coraline”) and almost every science-fiction
film in the last decade recklessly blended together. The idea
is creepy, freaky, thought-provoking, and definitely interesting,
riddled with imminent disaster, conspiracies and murder. But with
a short runtime and entirely too much to define, Surrogates suffers
from a neat and tidy conclusion that cheats the complexity of
the setting.
Very early on, when Greer admits that every perfectly proportioned
surrogate is probably just a fat guy, lounging around in a bathrobe,
inappropriately exposed, it’s clear that the writers aren’t
trying to hide the silliness of the concepts their world is based
upon. Who knew that such heavy science-fiction themes could be
so purposefully comical? Usually these films try incredibly hard
to convince the audience that the ideas are plausible, or at the
very least to suspend disbelief. The unintentional humor is usually
unstoppable, but in Surrogates, at least for a few fleeting scenes,
it is wholeheartedly embraced. Apparently even in a world of fake
people, Bruce Willis can still keep it real.
- The Massie Twins

"But it’s like “The Island,” “I, Robot,” “The Stepford Wives,” “Minority Report,” “Terminator” (and even “Coraline”) and almost every science-fiction film in the last decade recklessly blended together. "
They blended the best of everything but just ended up with sludge.