Many elements are familiar,
including the characters of The Joker, Alfred and Batgirl and locations
such as Arkham Asylum. But in an attempt to make Gotham and its
young female heroes hip, even more things are different. Birds of
Prey goes against every major aspect Christopher Nolan has tried
to define in Batman Begins and The Dark Knight. Nolan’s vision
places Batman in a world of serious rivals and deadly consequences,
as well as realistic explanations for his crime fighting abilities.
Instead of sticking to realism, Birds of Prey allows its characters
to possess superhuman powers that transcend mere intelligence and
high-tech weaponry. It is this startling X-Men mutation factor that
is most disheartening to see in a Batman spinoff.
And of course the dialogue doesn’t help to ground an already
goofy premise with unbelievable superheroes. “We’re
the good guys,” explains Helena - so that the audience certainly
won’t forget. “Why don’t you carry any weapons?”
inquires detective Reese, a police officer intent on discovering
the truths behind Oracle’s team of elite crime fighters.
“I am the weapon,” queries Huntress, as she eludes
the detective with a quick cut to her catlike eyes and a ludicrous
tiger roar sound effect accompaniment. Helena complains about
due recognition from the public, yet doesn’t wear a mask,
and Dinah gets caught up in ridiculous dramas at school. Most
often characters talk to themselves to inform the audience of
the progression of the story, and nearly all of the dialogue is
sadly humorous due to its poor timing or generic phrasing.
Whether the eye-candy trio squares off against Darkstrike, a
mysterious water assassin, underground gladiator fighting rings,
copes with New Gotham High School, or defends against the assassins
of Harley Quinn, Birds of Prey doesn’t feel like a Batman
series, and certainly doesn’t feel original. Often painfully
bad dialogue, silly story arcs and dreadful acting round out each
episode, which makes the Gotham Girls South Park-style web series
special feature more enjoyable than the appropriately short Birds
of Prey series.
- Mike Massie